Have you ever noticed that She never smiles in photographs? I used to think it was just that She was unhappy But now I know it's something else Something I had never known She can never stop herself From thinking of what might have been And does she pretend To keep me from breaking And does she pretend And what should I expect from someone so broken? And when we fell in love I thought I could make her smile again But the camera never lies you know It's true that she's still waiting And when we make love it seems That she's not always there with me I can never tell if she's Gone somewhere, I can never be And does she pretend To keep me from breaking And does she pretend And what should I expect from someone so broken? And if we had a second chance To live our lives out again Would she smile in photographs And never have to pretend