Jamie, why'd you have to say
You're not in love with me?
I guess I knew it all along
I just thought that I could prove you wrong
Riley, why's it so hard to
Wanna try with me?
I guess I knew it all the way
I just thought that this could be my day
Riley, why aren't you willing
To even try with me?
Come over here and just lie with me
Come over and just lie with me
Just lie to me, yeah
Jamie, why'd you have to say
You're not in love with me?
I guess I knew it all along
I just thought that I could prove you wrong
I just thought that I could prove you wrong
Jamie, why'd you have to say
You're not in love with me?