Every light is on but I'm still here in the dark Got the music up loud trying to drown out all my thoughts Where to start Said I'm in love, you didn't say it back A New York City heart gone black Coz that look on your face said you just didn't fall Was the last kiss we had the last one after all All this time, maybe I was just too blind So should I call you up Should I call you up, or baby should we call it a night Left me standing here going over every line Downtown subway drawing circles on the glass tonight Guess that I Held a balloon up and dreamed we'd float But I can't make you feel something you don't And that look on your face said you just didn't fall Was the last kiss we had the last one after all All this time, maybe I was just too blind Should I call you up Should I call you up, or baby should we call it a night Maybe you were never mine That look on your face said you just didn't fall Was the last kiss we had the last one after all All this time, maybe I just loved the lie Should I call you up When it's not enough Should I call you up or baby should we call it a night