The first time I broke it was the first time I'd ever been kissed
Oh but I took it to make it the first on my list
A beautiful family who loved me despite all of my lies
Sometimes I still hear her, faced on my shoulder
She cries, she cries
I'm sorry, Molly Dean, I didn't know I could be so mean
I'm sorry, Natalie, for all the things that I hadn't seen
I'm sorry, Mandy, you were first in the stream
And finally, I beg of thee
Forgive me
Molly was the first in the sexual kind of affair
Obsession made friends with jealousy, she would just stare
And all of my arrows in my quiver, none of made true
The stinging position of hate, my target was you
I'm sorry, Molly Dean, I didn't know I could be so mean
I'm sorry, Natalie, for all the things that I hadn't seen
I'm sorry, Mandy, you were first in the stream
And finally, I beg of thee
Forgive me
This one's with strangers who I make friends with deep in the dark
Daylight begins I forgotten that I've left my mark
I turn around, can I explain the damage that's done?
Justice will find me, will I find I have no one
That I have no one
I'm sorry, Molly Dean, I didn't know I could be so mean
I'm sorry, Natalie, for all the things I hadn't seen
I'm sorry, Mandy, 'cause you were first in the stream
And finally, I beg of thee
Forgive me
Oh, forgive me
Oh, forgive me