I heard you in the kitchen Talking it over What was I thinking Having you over? She's your girl And I'm not her I don't know Why you look At me that way I wish I didn't want you The way I pretend not to I wish I didn't wish you would call I wish I didn't have to Pretend that I don't want you I wish I didn't want you at all What were you thinking Pulling me closer? You had me dreaming You were over But she's your girl And I'm not her I don't know What you wanted Me to say I wish I didn't want you The way I pretend not to I wish I didn't wish you would call I wish I didn't have to Pretend that I don't want you I wish I didn't want you at all Cause every time you're close to me All I wanna do is stay And whenever you call my name I can't walk away And every time you look at me All I wanna do is say Come a little closer now baby Don't walk away I wish I didn't want you The way I pretend not to I wish I didn't wish you would call I wish I didn't have to Pretend that I don't want you I wish I didn't want you at all