Heaven only knows where we went wrong Thought I was in the place where I belong However hard I tried, I was living a lie I've been thinking My mind's racing all the time How I wish I could love you, baby Right here in my arms and hold you, baby I don't know what I'm afraid of I keep falling in and out of love You're everything I'd ever ask for But what I feel makes me unsure There's something missing I don't quite know what But let me tell you for once in my life How I wish I could love, baby Right here in my arms and hold you, baby I don't know what I'm afraid of I keep falling in and out of love I must be going crazy To let go of someone like you But what can I do We can't hold on to maybes When we both know that it's not true That we're made for each other I'm in and out of love How I wish I could love you, baby Right here in my arms and hold you, baby I don't know what I'm afraid of I keep falling in and out Keep falling in and out of love Oooh, In and out of love