I should be pulling up in your driveway
Headlights off so your daddy don't see
'Cause he never liked me
Something 'bout this don't feel right
You should be with me tonight
I just got memories in the back of my mind
And they're proving every reason why
It should've been you, should've been us
Should've been two young hearts falling in love
It should've been my heart in your hands
Should be your eyes that I'm lost in
It should've been
Should've been, should've been
Baby it could've been
What if it would've been us?
If I saw you I'd apologize and tell you
We were something special, like a whole 'nother level
So tell me why aren't we together?
It should've been you, should've been us
Should've been two young hearts falling in love
It should've been my heart in your hands
Should be your eyes that I'm lost in
It should've been
Should've been, should've been
Baby it could've been
What if it would've been us?
Should've been, should've been
Baby it could've been
What if it would've been us?
Something 'bout this don't feel right
You should be with me tonight
Oh you should be right here with me
Right here with me
Baby it should've been you, should've been us
Should've been two young hearts falling in love
It should've been my heart in your hands
Should be your eyes that I'm lost in
It should've been
Should've been, should've been
Baby it could've been
What if it would've been us?
Should've been, should've been
Baby it could've been
What if it would've been us?
It should've been my heart in your hands
Should be your eyes that I'm lost in
It should've been