The secret was me drinking in that bar that night
And a stranger walking up who I let catch my eye
Small talk was easy
Time it just flew by
The secret was me drinking in that bar that night
The secret was me putting my hand on her back
You hang on to every word when she's got lips like that
Oh, I fell a little hard
Every time she laughed
The secret was me putting my hand on her back
Somewhere between the secret and the truth
Is a choice you make that you just can't undo
Oh, the fine line between a stranger's touch and losing you
Lies somewhere between the secret and the truth
In-between, where I was and where I should've been
Is a good man's prayer and a lonely midnight sin
But there's no way justify
Or ever make amends
In-between, where I was and where I should've been
Yeah, somewhere between the secret and the truth
Is a motel room that I shouldn't walk into
Oh, the fine line between a stranger's kiss and losing you
Lies somewhere between the secret and the truth
♪
The truth is I should've never let it get that far
The truth is God knows I'm just a man
Truth is, I bought her one more drink and left her sitting there
And drove straight home to you
Yeah, she's just the secret
Oh, baby, you're the truth
And I ain't ever losing you