Marchin' in line in the halls of my Catholic school Seven Hail Marys if I copped an attitude And God was a word I had spoken but I hardly knew Kneelin' down at the altar with no clue who I was talkin' to Stumblin' 'round Athens with frat boys in hot pursuit Left me starin' at the ceilin', pissed off and feelin' used Wasted and worn out and wonderin', "Where do I fit?" And scared as hell 'cause I knew I was different What's it like to be normal? To want what normal girls should? God knows life would be easier If I could be normal, then trust me, I would Trust me, I would ♪ Did they want what's best or did they want what's easiest? 'Cause I tried my best, but God damn, was I curious And she had me high as the sun on a Saturday afternoon With no way to unsee this side of me that she introduced What's it like to be normal? To want what normal girls should? God knows life would be easier If I could be normal, then trust me, I would Trust me, I would Trust me, I would Trust me, I would ♪ Curled up on the couch, you look just as worn out as me Tryin' to act certain in a world of uncertainty And one night, the moonlight took over and I kissed your lips The world told us to fit in, but we did the opposite The world told us to fit in, but we did the opposite