She left me there in the garage Staggering from the barrage She waltzed away as my face fell Chalk another sucker to the list she's making He laughed at me from up above Tucked away with his new love All I wanted was to tell him what she meant to me But he gave me nothing That was when snow fell in october Don't be that Judas Please remember Sympathy beats apathy so bleed compassion That was the day I truly lost her He was the Judas Such a coward I'll erase my memory Forget what happened Some things we can't do ourselves Pennies into wishing wells She turned awkward silence into painful laughter You know I'd do the same for you Yet you rolled how the heartless do I was so much better to you But I wish I wasn't That was when snow fell in october Don't be that Judas Please remember Sympathy beats apathy so bleed compassion That was the day I truly lost her He was the Judas Such a coward I'll erase my memory Forget what happened Maybe there's truth in the claim I'm selfish But I'm not crazy My name and a heart on the back of your arm Still freshly inked and scabbing When you said forever I guess you meant a week