When we first met Your hair was in your eyes Didn't believe a word you said But I loved those pretty lies Now I'm the kind of person Who acts how I feel And for a moment in time I know what we had was real You stay with me No, you never really go In the bars out on Broadway In the chords of this piano What a goddamn mess Fate is such a joke But I hope one day we'll be laughing Together or alone Together or alone ♪ Last time I saw you You wouldn't look me in the eye I heard every word you said Knowing it was real this time My friends, they will talk In clichés on being free But the grass is always greener When it's something you can't see I hope that you find What it is you're looking for I'm just proud to have loved you Enough to ask for more In some other lifetime Would you pick me out again? Would I have chosen to stay And see us through until the end? See us through until the end?