Why did she stay with him is there something I missed Was it 'cause she was scared or was it how he kissed So why did she run to me when he made her cry What was I supposed to say to change her mind When every time she'd go back again Why did she stay with him Why did she stay with him What didn't I see Was I so wrong to think She could ever leave him for me Is that the way love is Is it cruel and unfair Can it make my two eye's See something that isn't there Could it make her just give in Why did she stay with him Why did she stay Did I do something wrong Did I come off too weak Or did I come on too strong I guess I lose, I guess he wins Why did she stay with him Why did she stay Did she just forget When I held her in my arms And all the things she said Will she think of me when she feels his skin Why did she stay with him