We were too good for each other
We were too good for the other
One excuse after another
Tears alone under the covers
You had always said you loved me
I had always said I loved you too
When did all these feelings turn into memories?
We were too close
We were too far from the truth
So I swept you under the rug
Like dust
And you kept me on your bookshelf
With the rest of the pages you flipped through
And through
And through
We were too good for each other
We were too good for the other
One excuse after another
Tears alone under the covers
You had always said you loved me
I had always said I loved you too
When did all these feelings turn into memories?
We clinked our teacups
Held our pinkies out and promised
We'd be alone together
Found our future sketched on the sidewalk
But when the rain came down it washed out
And down
And out
We were too good for each other
We were too good for the other
One excuse after another
Tears alone under the covers
You had always said you loved me
I had always said I loved you too
When did all these feelings turn into memories?
We were too good for each other
We were too good for the other
One excuse after another
Tears alone under the covers
You had always said you loved me
I had always said I loved you too
When did all these feelings turn into memories?