Was loving you my mistake? Am I to blame? Oh baby, listen Never knew someone like me Could be loved so vulnerably Till you came along Wish I never had a taste Toothpaste kisses on my faces You could do no wrong While I was sleeping and dreaming of you You were up with another He put his hand on your thigh It plays out in my mind I don't know if I'll ever recover What am I supposed to believe in now? If it ain't you And I plead to the sky Oh why? Why, why, why Why do you do what you do? Now I'm lost in emotion I don't sleep until the mornin' Was I damned by design Right person wrong time Now my head is buried in my hands babe To hide these tears that I cry How the truth set me free But all I feel is misery And the questions start flooding my mind What am I supposed to believe in now? If it ain't you And I plead to the sky Oh why? Why, why, why Why do you do what you do?