You were like a brother to me Like a member of the family Stayin' over on Christmas Eve Yeah But every time I look at you now All I see is her stormin' out On the day her world came crashin' down That girl She had a beautiful heart that you shattered like glass That girl Is still in love with you Whoa If I could, I'd erase every tear drop stain you left on her face Sometimes I wish you never knew That girl I see the guilt glaze over your eyes Every time you apologize 'Cause your story's still full o' lies Yeah Gotta know where I'm comin' from Like a bullet out of a gun What you did can't be undone And I'd do anything for That girl She had a beautiful heart that you shattered like glass That girl Is still in love with you Whoa If I could, I'd erase every tear drop stain you left on her face Sometimes I wish you never knew That girl Everyday livin' drowning in your regrets She may forgive, but I won't forget What you did to That girl She had a beautiful heart that you shattered like glass That girl Is still in love with you If I could, I'd erase every tear drop stain you left on her face Sometimes I wish you never knew (Whoa) That girl That girl Oh That girl